Pro wins
Olympia titles
Shows entered
Years active
Direct Record Michelle Hurst 2–3 Abbi Tartaglione · 5 shared shows
| Year | Competition | Division | Michelle Hurst | Abbi Tartaglione | Winner | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | IFBB Masters Olympia Pro | Bikini Masters 40+ | 14 | 12 | Abbi Tartaglione | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2022 | Sasquatch Pro | Bikini | 12 | 11 | Abbi Tartaglione | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2022 | IFBB Nashville Fit Show Pro | Bikini | 10 | 17 | Michelle Hurst | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2018 | IFBB Iron Games | Bikini | 12 | 16 | Michelle Hurst | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2018 | IFBB Salt City Showdown | Bikini | 16 | 12 | Abbi Tartaglione | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |