Pro wins
Olympia titles
Shows entered
Years active
Direct Record Rachel McLish 5–0 Carolyn Cheshire · 5 shared shows
| Year | Competition | Division | Rachel McLish | Carolyn Cheshire | Winner | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1984 | Ms. Olympia | Women's Bodybuilding | 2 | 16 | Rachel McLish | en.wikipedia.org ↗ |
| 1983 | Ms. Olympia | Women's Bodybuilding | 2 | 7 | Rachel McLish | en.wikipedia.org ↗ |
| 1982 | Ms. Olympia | Women's Bodybuilding | 1 | 14 | Rachel McLish | en.wikipedia.org ↗ |
| 1981 | Ms. Olympia | Women's Bodybuilding | 2 | 18 | Rachel McLish | en.wikipedia.org ↗ |
| 1980 | Ms. Olympia | Women's Bodybuilding | 1 | 13 | Rachel McLish | en.wikipedia.org ↗ |