Pro wins
Olympia titles
Shows entered
Years active
Direct Record Ashley Jenelle 3–2 Ashley Nicastro · 5 shared shows
| Year | Competition | Division | Ashley Jenelle | Ashley Nicastro | Winner | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Wings of Strength Chicago Pro | Bikini | 5 | 8 | Ashley Jenelle | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2019 | IFBB Toronto Pro Supershow | Bikini | 7 | 9 | Ashley Jenelle | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2018 | IFBB Pittsburgh Pro | Bikini | 12 | 6 | Ashley Nicastro | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2018 | IFBB Salt City Showdown | Bikini | 15 | 6 | Ashley Nicastro | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |
| 2018 | IFBB Indy Pro | Bikini | 3 | 5 | Ashley Jenelle | contests.npcnewsonline.com ↗ |